1986 Workshop
Maureen McGovern (Margaret White), Annie Golden (Carrie White), Laurie Beechman (Mrs. Gardner), Laura Dean (Sue Snell), Liz Callaway (Chris Hargensen), Todd Graff (Tommy Ross), Peter Neptune (Billy), Donna Murphy.
Stratford Production
Barbara Cook (Margaret White), Linzi Hateley (Carrie White), Darlene Love (Mrs. Gardner), Sally Ann Triplett (Sue Snell), Charlotte D'Amboise (Chris Hargensen), Paul Gyngell (Tommy Ross), Gene Anthony Ray (Billy).
Broadway Production
BETTY BUCKLEY (Margaret White), Linzi Hateley (Carrie White), Darlene Love (Mrs. Gardner), Sally Ann Triplett (Sue Snell), Charlotte D'Amboise (Chris Hargensen), Paul Gyngell (Tommy Ross), Gene Anthony Ray (Billy).
OFF BROADWAY REVIVAL 2012
Marin Mazzie (Margaret White)
Molly Ranson (Carrie White)
Christy Altomare (Sue Snell)
Carmen Cusack (Lynn Gardner)
Jeanna de Waal (Chris Hargensen)
Derek Klena (Tommy Ross)
Ben Thompson (Billy Nolan)
Wayne Wilcox (Mr. Stephens & Others)
Corey Boardman (George)
Blair Goldberg (Norma)
F. Michael Haynie (Freddy)
Andy Mientus (Stokes)
Elly Noble (Helen)
Jen Sese (Frieda)
Mackenzie Bell (Understudy for Lynn Gardner, Chris Hargensen, Frieda, Helen, Norma)
Jake Boyd (Understudy for Tommy Ross, Mr. Stephens, Freddy, George, Stokes)
Anne Tolpegin (Standby for Margaret White, Lynn Gardner)
Molly Ranson (Carrie White)
Christy Altomare (Sue Snell)
Carmen Cusack (Lynn Gardner)
Jeanna de Waal (Chris Hargensen)
Derek Klena (Tommy Ross)
Ben Thompson (Billy Nolan)
Wayne Wilcox (Mr. Stephens & Others)
Corey Boardman (George)
Blair Goldberg (Norma)
F. Michael Haynie (Freddy)
Andy Mientus (Stokes)
Elly Noble (Helen)
Jen Sese (Frieda)
Mackenzie Bell (Understudy for Lynn Gardner, Chris Hargensen, Frieda, Helen, Norma)
Jake Boyd (Understudy for Tommy Ross, Mr. Stephens, Freddy, George, Stokes)
Anne Tolpegin (Standby for Margaret White, Lynn Gardner)